ANOTHER MUSICAL MUSING, 5 January 2024–“AS TIME GOES BY”: A Song Older Than Me From a Movie Not Quite As

In this day and age, we are all conscious of the passage of time. And, here we are with another–hopefully of many more–New Years. Take the time, despite what we keep read in the newspapers, to enjoy! 

Moving on . . . Let’s roast one more musical “chestnut” as we start up these “Musical Musings” in the year of ’24. So, why not begin with a “timely” film favorite “As Time Goes By.” Today we remember it mostly as an earworm from the movie “Casablanca” that premiered exactly eighty years ago–1942.  It still resonates for the tech-savvy of us in the 2020s! As a plus, it gives us an opportunity to explore the musical oeuvre of, alas, one of many now obscure and forgotten songwriters of Tin Pan Alley.

While most of us know this song from its truncated version in the movie, . . .

. . . it did have a much earlier life.  It was written by New Jersey’s own Herman Hupfeld (1894-1951) in 1931 for the Broadway musical “Everybody’s Welcome.” 

While this song was ranked at Number Two on the American Film Institute’s best songs of all time, after “Over the Rainbow,” it seems to be the only song by Hupfeld that anyone today remembers and plays.  He did, however, write songs like “When Yuba Plays The Rhumba On The Tuba“, “I’ve Got To Get Up And Go To Work”, “Are You Making Any Money?,” “A Hut in Hoboken”, and, of course, “Let’s Put Out the Lights and Go to Sleep.”  Such is the cachet of the movies! 

Oh, why not? Click or tap on the triangle in the next image for somewhat of a musical diversion if not a treat.

But I digress . . .

“As Time Goes By” was sung in the 1931 musical by Frances Williams . . .

. . . but was first recorded by the crooner and bandleader Rudy Vallee and his “Connecticut Yankees.”  This was a hit record in 1931. Click or tap on the triangle in the next image to listen to this version.

By far, however, the best-known take on our song is the one from “Casablanca” as sung by the character “Sam,” played by Dooley Wilson, at the request of “Ilse,” played by Ingrid Bergman. 

Wilson was a drummer and actor—alas, not a piano player.  So, in the movie the piano music was dubbed.  Such is the magic of film! Click or tap on the triangle in the next image for a look and listen.

If you are interested in the history of collectible musical instruments and don’t mind another digression, the piano that Wilson “played” in the movie—built with a shortened keyboard, 58 instead of 88 keys, and decorated in a “Moroccan” motif—was recently restored and sold at a Bonham’s auction for $3.4 million! 

For you buffs of old-school jazz/popular songs, such as “As Time Goes By,” here are the words for the first verse.  The chorus and bridge are, of course, what we are most familiar with. The rhymes are, to my eldie ears, much more listenable–and witty– than today’s rap! Just sayin’ . . .

VERSE:  This day and age we’re living in, Gives cause
for apprehension,

With speed and new invention, And things like third dimension.

Yet we get a trifle weary, With Mister Einstein’s theory.

So we must get down to earth, At times relax, relieve the tension.



No matter what the progress, Or what may yet be proved.

The simple facts of life are such, They cannot be removed.



CHORUS:  You must remember this, A kiss
is still a kiss.

.   .  .

Of course, there are hundreds of covers of this favorite tune.  Here are a few just to illustrate the variety of interpretations! Click or tap on the triangle in any of the images to give a listen.

As an aside, the producers of the movie “Casablanca” wanted to cut the “As Time Goes By” scene from the movie fearing that it was a bit too long and really didn’t “push” the plot.  Ingrid Bergman, however, had moved on to another film (“For Whom the Bell Tolls”) and had cut her hair for that role.  It was deemed impossible in that day and age to reshoot so, against their better judgement, the producers left the song in.  How musical history is made!

So, here’s an after-Christmas earworm to kick in the new year!  You’re welcome!

Just so we don’t spend the rest of the week humming or whistling “As Time Goes By,” over and over again, let’s bring back out our forgotten songwriter, Herman Hupfeld, for one more fling. This time with the ultimate crooner, Bing Crosby, and “Let’s Put Out the Lights and Go to Sleep.”

So, as time goes by, have a good night, have a good year, have a good sleep, appreciate good but forgotten songwriters, remember to turn off the lights, and STAY TUNED!